First Impressions- Fall 2018 Anime Season

School buses are jamming up traffic and it’s too cold to turn my A/C on so it must finally be fall again. With that comes a bunch of new anime, and as is generally the case with the fall, there’s a lot of big titles going head to head. Working through all of them to find out exactly which ones are worthwhile is certainly gonna be an interesting task, especially with how streaming is affecting how much of this stuff we get at once, but it’s basically what I’m here for so let’s hop to it

Ratings Scale

Bad: Stay away far away from this one.  Not worth watching

Decent: Has some okay elements to it. Might be worth giving a  couple of episodes to see how it goes

Good: Fairly solid show. Should be worth keeping up with for now

Great: Really good show. Definitely worth seeing if you get the chance

Excellent: Really outstanding show. Absolutely worth following .


Double Decker- Doug & Kirill

Synopsis: The city state of Lisvalletta. Two suns rise above this city, and the people here live peaceful lives, but in the shadows crime and illegal drugs run rampant. Among them is the dangerous, highly lethal drug “Anthem” which casts a dark shadow over the city. The SEVEN-O Special Crime Investigation Unit specializes in cracking down on Anthem. This unit operates in two man “buddy” teams in what’s called the “Double Decker System” to tackle the problem. Doug Billingham is a seasoned investigator, and joining him is Kirill Vrubel, whose abilities are mysterious and unknown

First Impressions: While there’s been a lot of anticipation from the simulcast fandom over things like SSSS. Gridman, and Goblin Slayer, this one was probably my most anticipated non-sequel of the season. I’m a huge fan of Tiger & Bunny and I’ve spent pretty much every year since 2011, praying that Sunrise would get a clue and give us another season. Those prayers were answered…sort of as a sequel is apparently in the works, and this show is a spin-off that’s meant to be part of whatever it is they’re up to. It’s a strange situation to say the least but the good news is, even if you haven’t seen Tiger & Bunny this show seems to basically be it’s own thing and it’s pretty easy to jump into.

The premise is essentially a futuristic buddy-cop comedy following a dorky rookie named Kirill who wants to become a hero and a brooding veteran named Doug along side a few female co-workers who have pairs of their own. Given that Tiger & Bunny was more or less a buddy-cop show mixed with superheroes, a literal buddy cop show is an odd direction to go in, but it certainly fits that style well enough and the show’s got some pretty solid comedic chops, and some pretty slick animation on the action side of things. It also helps that the characters all seem pretty likable so far, and it even seems like the show might have some solid gay representation going by the ED song, which was kind of Tiger & Bunny’s sole Achilles’ heel for me. I’ve watched both episodes that are currently available so it kind of goes without saying I’m all in on this one, but if you’re hesitant on it because it’s connected to another show, I recommend giving it a shot.

Rating: Great

 

RErideD- Derrida, who leaps through time

Synopsis: In 2050 engineer Derrida Yvain is famous for his contribution to “Autonomous Machine DZ,” at his father’s company, Rebuild. But when he and his colleague Nathan discover a dangerous flaw in their creation, their warnings go ignored. The next day after Nathan’s daughter Mage’s birthday party, the group barely escapes an attack by unknown forces, leading to Derrida’s unwitting captivity in cryogenic stasis. Ten years later, he emerges in a world at war with the mechanical lifeforms he helped create. Now, he fights to survive his nightmare future to make good his promise to “Take care of Mage.”

First Impressions: Alright so I know the first four episodes of this have been made available as of the time I typed this, but these ARE supposed to be first impressions and plowing through four episodes just to give my initial two-cents seems excessive so I’m just going off episode 1. Having said all that I was kind of mixed on checking this out. On the one hand it’s helmed by director Takuya Sato of Steins; Gate fame and also has Yoshitoshi ABe, the character designer for Serial Expermients Lain attached to it, which were certainly strong enough staff members to draw my attention. On the other hand I didn’t hear particularly great things about the premiere screening so I was hesitant to set myself up for disappointment. For all that though, the first episode was…okay. As far as hard sci-fi plots go, nothing in particular stands out about the story and it hasn’t introduced any clear themes yet, but it’s not boring, and the episode ends on a strong enough cliffhanger that I felt compelled to see where it goes. Similarly, none of the characters stand out so far, the lead included, but none of them were particularly unlikable so it’s pretty watchable in that respect as well.

The real issue here though is that the show is pretty bland looking. While hard sci-fi shows aren’t necessarily obligated to look good, a strong visual aesthetic usually helps in making the worlds of those settings feel believable or exciting and this show has none of that going on. To make matters worse, the character designs look pretty simplistic in animation, and to the point where you’d never be able to tell someone as talented ABe was involved with this. Obviously none of these things will be deal breakers for anyone going into it totally blind, and it’s perfectly watchable but it does kind of feel like a waste of talent. But like I said, I was left curious to see where the story was headed so I guess I’ll be sticking around for at least one more episode, I just kinda wish this looked better

Rating: Decent

 

The Girl in Twilight

Synopsis: Constantly on the lookout for her next big adventure, the cheerful and kind Asuka Tsuchimiya is always ready to try new things with her high school friends from the Crystal Radio Club. One day, the group performs a ritual from an urban myth just for fun. However, several conditions had fallen into place to put the ritual in motion, opening the door to a new world of gold and jet black. In this world, Asuka finds a different version of herself and soon finds out that some doors were never meant to be opened.

First Impressions: I was a little interested to see this one by virtue of the fact that it has a notable visual novel writer attached to it, and I’m always down for potentially neat anime originals. That interest slightly died when it seemed like this show was going to fall into the hands of PonyCan USA but somehow it ended up in Sentai’s instead, and good thing too because it’s off to a pretty solid start. Much of the episode’s first half is spent introducing us to our lead heroines as they goof around and dabble in the occult and while none of them stand out quite yet, they come off as fairly believable teens rather than moeblobs which is always a plus. Of course things take a pretty drastic turn in the second half when the girls’ antics cause them to stumble into another dimension and our lead Akane, ends up meeting an alternate version of herself with a chip on her shoulder. It certainly caught my attention to say the least and unlike DErideD, this show actually looks pretty good and seems like it could maintain a decent sci-fi aesthetic. The only downside on that department is that it seems like it’ll use 3DCG for the action scenes, but the stuff we got here looked pretty solid by anime standards so hopefully it’ll be an asset and not a distraction. Story-wise it’s hard to say where any of this is going based on the premiere but it got enough right that I’m more than happy to give it another watch. Check it out.

Rating: Good

 

That Time I Got Reincarnated As A Slime

Synopsis: Lonely thirty-seven-year-old Satoru Mikami is stuck in a dead-end job, unhappy with his mundane life, but after dying at the hands of a robber, he awakens to a fresh start in a fantasy realm…as a slime monster! As he acclimates to his goopy new existence, his exploits with the other monsters set off a chain of events that will change his new world forever!

First Impressions: Welp it’s time for our seasonal dose of isekai, but this is one I was at least morbidly curious about, thanks to the clearly weird premise demonstrated in the title. For the most part I’d say this curiosity was pretty well rewarded. On the surface it’s not too different from other isekai stories, the protagonist starts off as an unnamed office worker who dies and ends up reincarnated into fantasy RPG world, and he’s granted abilties that make him pretty overpowerful, but it’s got quite a few things going for it. One is obviously the concept of having the protagonist as a non-human entity, and the show plays that up for all it’s worth (though going by the OP he’ll eventually gain some kind of humanoid form so he can have his inevitable harem), but it also has a pretty solid sense of humor with much of the episode’s second half centering around the protagonist forming an odd bur endearing friendship with a dragon that looks like he’d be the final boss of a Final Fantasy game. This is all aided by some surprisingly strong visual direction that gives the show enough extra flair that it actually feels like the staff involved are having fun with it, compared to how much a lot of other isekai stuff feels like it’s running on auto-pilot. I have no idea if this show will be able the amount of goodwill the premiere provided, but I was entertained enough that I’ll certainly give it another episode or two.

Rating: Good

 

Run With the Wind

Synopsis: Tokyo-Hakone Round-Trip College Ekiden Race or “Hakone Ekiden,” one of the biggest university marathon relay races in Japan. The race is held every year on January 2-3 and goes between Tokyo and Hakone and back, for a total run of of nearly 217.9 km (about 135.4 miles).

First Impressions: While I didn’t really know anything about the source material here, the staff attached to it was enough to catch my attention since there’s quite a bit of overlap with Haikyu and that’s a show I like a lot. That certainly shows in the visual presentation as the character designs ring quite a few similarities and the animation looks pretty solid so far which is definitely a plus for a sport like running which obviously requires a lot of motion. Far as the actual material goes I felt a little mixed. The episode made the weird decision shift around some  chronological events in what seemed to be a bid to introduce the show’s ensemble as fast as possible and while it didn’t totally kill my interest, there was a quite a bit of whiplash there. To it’s credit though the cast is pretty diverse as in addition to a few generic pretty boys we get a couple of gruffer looking ones, and even a black guy thrown into a mix which certainly isn’t what you’d come to expect from something clearly hoping to strike it with the fujoshi crowd.

Of course with a total of 10 dudes introduced this premiere doesn’t really have enough time to make them all stand out, but I do appreciate the diversity. Far as the story goes, nothing’s really grabbed my attention yet since the show has yet to make it’s case on why one of the leads is so driven to make it to the championships in track, but I imagine that won’t take long to get fleshed out. Right now the only thing seriously holding me to this one is the novelty of having a black guy as part of a bishie ensemble but I like sports shows, and nothing here seemed it would raise any serious red flags so at the very least I’m probably willing to give it another episode.

Rating: Decent

Rascal Does Not Dream of Bunny Girl Senpai

Synopsis: “Puberty syndrome – Abnormal experiences rumored on the internet to be caused by sensitivity and instability during adolescence. This year, Sakuta Azusagawa, a second-year student at a high school near Enoshima, meets several girls that are experiencing this “puberty syndrome.” For instance, he meets a wild bunny girl in the library. She turns out to be an actress on hiatus, Mai Sakurajima, who is also his senior at the school. For some reason, no one else can see this enchanting girl. How did she become invisible…?

First Impression: Alongside our seasonal dose of isekai is the seasonal world salad title light novel show, and this one looks to fill that void. Didn’t really know anything about this one aside from the wacky title and going by the first episode I’m not quite sure exactly what it’s aiming for. On the surface it seems to following in the footsteps of titles like SNAFU by having a protagonist who’s kind of an apathetic jerk getting involved with a female classmate who’s quiet and socially isolated, but there also seem to be a potential mystery going on regarding the heroines and the “Adolescent Syndrome” that seems to be cursing them. While there’s plenty of set-up here for the latter, much of the time here is spent introducing us to the protagonist who frankly didn’t really come off as endearing enough to hold my attention for 20 minutes and the chemistry between him and the main heroine didn’t quite do it for me either. More than anything though, nothing here really grabbed me one way or the other, and I’m honestly not that sure what I watched. It was fairly watchable though I guess so it might be someone else’s speed but I’m not sure if I’m that interested to see where this is going.

Rating: Decent

 

Between the Sky and Sea

Synopsis: Fish suddenly disappeared on Earth. The Ministry of Fisheries has initiated the experimental program of creating ‘Aquatic Orbs’, farming fish in encapsulated bodies of water in space. Six girls are selected as candidates to become fishers who will go into space to catch new species of fish. From Onomichi City to the cosmos, this is the story of aspiring girls aiming to be Space Fishers!

First Impressions: I knew literally nothing about this one going but somewhere along the way I was able to piece together this was a mobile game adaption and sure enough I was right on the money. Aside from stuff like Rage of Bahamut: Genesis, these tend to strike out more often than not when it comes to being entertaining but I actually found this to be pretty okay. The characters are pretty much the usual assortment of moeblob archetypes with nothing to make them feel distinct or close to actual women, but the premise of fishing in space was absurd enough to catch my attention and this managed to get some decent mileage out of that. The mechanics of said space fishing are pretty clearly based on a mobile app (something it rather shamelessly doesn’t bother hiding surprisingly enough)  but they still felt kind of neat regardless and if nothing else it made me kind of want to check out the mobile game this was based on. Can’t really say if this is absolutely worth a watch since I was mainly just entertained by the premise more than anything, but if that sounds amusing to you, this might be worth a peek. As for me, I’m not totally sure if I’ll go any further but the odds are better than with most other mobile game adaptions I’ve watched so if nothing else, it’s at least accomplished that much

Rating: Decent

 

Zombieland Saga

Synopsis: A typical morning. The usual music. Their normal lives. The peace these seven girls experience will suddenly be destroyed. By the living dead… zombies. A reality that they never wanted a part of, an amazing and terrifying zombie world. They all share one wish: “We want to live.” These girls will struggle through this saga, in order to achieve a miracle.

First Impressions: I was extremely curious about this show, because like most folks, I was wonder what the heck it was gonna be. The producers waited until the last possible moment to give us a staff list and a trailer and usually when a show is that vague in terms of promotion it’s either something extremely unexpected or it’s going through some serious production hell. MAPPA’s general track record made the likelihood of the latter unlikely so I was banking on the former and having walked away from this I honestly haven’t a clue what I just watched. The first few minutes tease the start of a typical idol show, then quickly swerves into a zombie apocalypse, only to end up teasing the possibility of zombies as a idol group, before (seemingly) settling in the idea of zombie idol girls doing death metal. If that sounds absolutely absurd, rest assured the act of watching it is even more bizarre, and the show went through so many shifts over the course of 20 minutes that my jaw was stuck on the floor almost the whole way through. Weird as it was there are two things I know for certain: 1) it was pretty funny and while not everything was laugh out loud hilarious, the timing for every punchline was downright incredible, 2) I’m absolutely down for more of…whatever this is. I’m not sure if anything I’ve said will properly prepare you for the experience but if at least part of it sounded amusing to you, I’d say give it a go.

Rating: Great

 

Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure: Golden Wind

Synopsis: Jotaro asks Koichi to travel to Naples to investigate a person known as Haruno Shiobana, whose real name is later revealed as Giorno Giovanna. The story follows Giorno in his goal to rise to the top of the Passione mafia group and turn it into a band of honorable thieves.

First Impressions: It’s been a long wait, but it’s finally time for some new Jojo’s. To be honest though I wasn’t totally sure how enthusiastic I was for this. Golden Wind has generally been regarded by Jojo’s diehards as one of the weakest entries, and the 6 or 7 chapters of the manga I skimmed through back when I still read manga scanlations didn’t really do much to keep my attention after the highs of Diamond is Unbreakable. All that said, more Jojo’s is still more Jojo’s and this premiere was pretty fun. Where as Diamond is Unbreakable had the aesthetic of a horror movie set in the suburbs, this seems to be more akin to a mafia drama, and our lead Giornno has already proven himself to be a lot more amoral than Josuke, with the matter of his connection to the Joestar bloodline only further complicating matters. It’s a pretty noticeable shift but the premiere has pulled it off pretty well and in spite of the fact that this season has gone through a pretty big change in directors, the in-house “style” of David Production’s take on Jojo’s is still as strong as ever, and manages to go from funny to terrifying without skipping a beat. The only big “negative” here is that compared to last couple of entries, this one is REALLY running on the assumption you’ve seen Diamond is Unbreakable and Stardust Crusaders so it’s not quite as newbie-friendly. However for all us Jojo’s fans out there, this seems like it’ll be a pretty good time.

Rating: Great

 

Hinomaru Sumo

Synopsis: A “small” new student, Ushio Hinomaru, appears before the weak little sumo club of Oodachi High School. The words “big” and “heavy” are the rules to this sport, which does not fit this newbie one bit, but Ushio surprises everyone. Ushio and the small sumo club climbs its way to the top with a goal to reach the highest rank, Hinoshita Kaisan.

First Impressions: Hinomaru Sumo has been running in JUMP for several years now but due to the lack of an anime adaption, and the fact that sumo’s such an unpopular sport that Viz would be pretty nuts to risk licensing the manga without one, I’ve never gotten the opportunity to check it out. Now that it has though, I was finally able to give it a shot and for the most part this was a pretty fun premiere. Ushio comes off as a fairly likable protagonist and while he’s come too far along in his physical stature for his dream of becoming the best sumo wrestler to work as an underdog story, the show drops some pretty strong suggestions that there’s more driving him than just a desire to win. The general aesthetic also seems to be leaning pretty hard into how much testosterone it can give off and while it’s not a standout in that respect, it does give the impression the sumo bouts could get pretty gritty. In terms of animation it just looks serviceable so far, but given this adaption is being done by modern-day GONZO, I didn’t have any major expectations about it looking good and so long it can stay relatively consistent it hopefully won’t hurt any of the matches. I wasn’t quite sure what to expect with this, but I walked away pretty entertained and while it’s hard to say if this’ll end up reaching the heights of some of favorite sports shows, I’m willing to give it the opportunity to impress me.

Rating: Good

 

UzaMaid!

Synopsis: Misha is an elementary school girl who lives with her father, having lost her mother at a young age. A new maid has joined their household, and on top of being an unusually muscular woman, she also has an excessive love for young girls!

First Impressions: This is yet another show I knew literally nothing about going in and I kinda wish I had so I could have stayed far, far away. At first glance this seems like it could be an innocent comedy involving a hyperactive maid who’s ex-military and a precocious little girl. That innocence goes right out the window when it quickly becomes apparent the maid is essentially a pedophile and most of the jokes are her creeping on a little girl who is rightlyfully angry and freaked out while the girl’s dad watches on in blissful ignorance. Between my current occupation and my general disgust for this kind of material, pretty much anything that makes a joke out of pedophilia is an automatic nope for me, and I wish I anime would stop with that. If I had anything nice to say about this it’s that the few minutes of it I managed to sit through were pretty well animated and so much in fact that I was kind of angry this much effort was put into something so gross, but the whole thing was so creepy I couldn’t even last the entire episode. Screw this.

Rating: Bad

 

Radiant

Synopsis: Seth is an aspiring wizard living in a pastoral village under the watchful eye of his mentor. Like all wizards, he is an “infected”—one of the few people that has survived contact with a Nemesis, creatures that fall from the sky and contaminate all they touch. His encounter gave him powers and led him to choose a path that seemed to be perfect—to become someone who hunts and fights the Nemesis. But Seth longs for a quest that goes beyond the simple hunt for monsters. He wants to find the place they come from, Radiant, and destroy it. Along with other wizards, he travels the world in search of Radiant, under the sinister eye of the Inquisition…

First Impressions: While I can’t say I was super eager about this one, I definitely wanted to give it a shot since I knew the original manga was penned by a French creator and anime adapting foreign comics isn’t something that happens every day. From everything I had heard though, it seemed like it was going to be a pretty basic shonen, but I generally like shonen so that wasn’t a big deal breaker for me. As for what I saw…yep it sure was a shonen. We’ve got everything from a loud idiot who wants to prove he’s the best like no one ever was, to the obligatory villagers who treat him like an outcast for being a constant screwup. Pretty much everything here is something the audience has likely seen before and it doesn’t helped that the anime is being directed by one Seiji Kishi whose work is so consistently mediocre that the quality of the show literally comes down to how good the source material is.  To it’s credit though, Seth can at least use magic somewhat, so there’s at least a chance it won’t pull the “he actually has the best power” bit that helps makes Black Clover insufferable to me. The only major standout here is the art design which isn’t amazing but offers a clean enough looking fantasy aesthetic that’s pleasant to look at, which is a little surprising considering NHK shows tend to look kinda shoddy. Nothing here really excited me in any particular way but it also seems pretty harmless for the moment and the fact that it ends on a cliffhanger gives me a bit of hope it might do something a little different. In the meantime though, I could probably use a Saturday morning cartoon so I’ll give this a couple more episodes to see if it can fit the bill.

Rating: Decent

 

Goblin Slayer

Synopsis: A young priestess has formed her first adventuring party, but almost immediately they find themselves in distress. It’s the Goblin Slayer who comes to their rescue–a man who’s dedicated his life to the extermination of all goblins, by any means necessary. And when rumors of his feats begin to circulate, there’s no telling who might come calling next…

First Impressions: Here we have the other big isekai of the season, and the one I was extremely nervous about. I’ve heard folks praising the light novels for years, but that praise has typically been in regards to how violent and unrelenting it is, which I guess might have been cool to teen me, but is generally something adult me couldn’t care less about. Still I figured I might as well give it a fair shake and the premiere was quite…something. Even without the title giving away the threat of the goblins, the framing of the first few minutes is extremely unsubtle about how screwed the party of adventures we follow are, and in a span of less than ten minutes things quickly escalate towards mob beatings and gang rape. Our heroine is saved from a similar fate (but not before a really uncomfortable close-up of her peeing herself in fear) by the titular Goblin Slayer who’s primary traits so far are that he’s ruthlessly efficient and…likes to hunt goblins I guess. Needless to say none of this appealed to me, and parts of it were outright gross, but for both better and worse I can totally see how this would appeal to a lot of edgy teens out there who find this sort of stuff to be “cool” and “shocking”. Studio WHITE FOX knows that too because the visual direction here is pretty stunning, and while the partial CG on Goblin Slayer is a little jarring, the overall presentation is enough that it would very much satisfy someone looking to sink their teeth into a violent action show. As for me though, I found this to be pretty vile and while to it’s partial credit, I was at least able to get through the whole first episode to critique it properly, this is basically one giant nope for me.

Rating: Bad

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *