The Promised Neverland Ep #04 Review

Synopsis: Emma, Ray and Norman are the three smartest children at an orphanage known as Grace Field House. Under the care and guidance of their caretaker known as “Mom”, the children live peaceful lives, with the one condition being that they are never to go beyond the gate that leads to outside of the orphanage. However one day, Emma and Norman discover the truth of what lies beyond the gate, and it’s one that will change their lives forever

The Review

Looks like it’s that time of the week again, as we delve deeper and deeper into the haunting world of The Promised Neverland. My feelings on this adaption have pretty much been one big roller coaster ride thus far, but fortunately I was spared of overthinking any of the anime’s choices this time. because this episode more or less played out how I expected and even ended exactly where I thought it would. Of course while I’m happy I don’t need to go through the extra effort of re-watching this episode to make my thoughts on it coherient, I suppose you’re here to read a review and not my neurotic ramblings so let’s get to it

While Krone decides to kids alone for awhile after last week’s rousing game of tag, Isabella is already onto her plan to oust her, and gives Krone a gentle, but condescending warning to do as she’s told if she ever wants to claim a Mom position. Unsurprisingly, this talk has the opposite effect on Krone who feels thoroughly humiliated, and she’s more determined than ever to root out the suspects. In a weird way, I kind of have to admire her level of determination. Sure she’s plotting to sell these kids out to a horrible death,  but if your smug boss talked down to you the way Isabella’s done since day one, wouldn’t you want to kick them to the curb and give them some comeuppance? Can’t exactly say I’d give Krone any awards for most relatable millenial, but she certainly is fun to watch.

Anyway while Krone starts working on her next scheme, our main trio decides to bring Gilda, and another orphan named Don into the fold. While Ray worries about the danger in bring newcomers on board when there’s the risk one of them could be a spy, Norman assures him he already has a strategy in mind to root out the rat. However, convincing Don and Gilda proves to be a little easier said than done, as Emma and Norman decide to obscure a bit of the truth by telling them that the kids are being sold off to child traffickers rather than eaten by demons, and that Conny and the other victims may still be alive. While Don and Gilda mostly buy into this explanation, it doesn’t sit well with Ray who thinks that they should have been blunt about the situation, and finds it cruel to give them a false sense of hope. Given Ray’s general disdain towards the prospect of saving the other kids, it’s interesting that he’d sympathize with them on this issue, and it gives a subtle impression that there may be a little more to Ray’s perspective than what we’ve been shown thus far.

While our heroes have a couple of additional allies though, that victory is seemingly short lived when Gilda sneaks out her bedroom in the middle of the night to meet with Krone. Emma silently suspects that this could mean that Gilda is the traitor, but it turns out that Krone was trying to lure in Gilda in order to get a read on exactly how much she knows, and to also see if she might make for a useful pawn. Unfortunately for Krone, Gilda is careful not to let anything slip, and while she’s still hot on the tails of Emma and gang, she hasn’t gotten any closer to catching them in the act.

With Gilda off the list of potential spies, Don seems like the next likely candidate, but before deciding to talk to the traitor in question, Norman asks for Emma and Ray’s perspectives on why someone would betray them, and if that traitor should be left behind. Ray deduces that the traitor is most likely being spared from shipping in exchange for selling out the other kids, but in spite of that possibility, Emma feels it’s necessary to save the traitor, not only because letting the other kids escape would likely result in that person’s death, but also because Emma knows her siblings well-enough to feel no one among them is truly evil, and wants to believe in them.

It’s hard not to find her thinking just a little naieve, but it’s equally hard to not want to believe she’s also kind of right, and I really appreciate the level of balance Emma’s optimism brings to this otherwise bleak tale. Norman seems to feel the same way as that sentiment leads him to confront the actual traitor, who turns out to be none other than Ray. With how apathetic Ray’s been towards the other kids, and the fact that he wasn’t present for the initial revelation about the truth behind the farm, it’s easy enough to guess he was the sellout, but it certainly doesn’t make the implications any less shocking as having one of our key players working for the other side is a pretty bold move to lay out this early on in the story. While we don’t yet know the details behind Ray’s supposed betrayal though, one thing that’s for sure is that excited to how that plays out.

Rating: 8.6/10

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *